Skip to main content

Is the Truth All a Lie?


Every single situation can have many different truths. Which one is right? Are they all? Are none? The difficult parts of those questions are that there are no correct answers. Disregarding true statistics and concrete facts, all truth is, is your perception of it. Many things impact how we perceive and think of the truth, such as bias and different rhetorical devices.

An individual's bias puts everything heard or seen through a unique lens. Rhetorical devices also go hand in hand with how everyone perceived the truth. Logos obviously show the direct truth through statistics and concrete facts, where pathos can call upon emotions that accentuate one’s bias. Pathos also aids in creating a personal connection with the audience and author, increasing the level of trust between the two. The third rhetorical device is what embodies that trust, ethos. Truth goes hand in hand with ethos. Ethos and credibility with author builds trust that what the author is saying is the truth, or at least their perception of the truth. With the things they carried, I trusted Tim O’Brien with everything he said. By stating many times that he veteran and writer, O’Brien built up his ethos throughout
the entire novel. With that, I believed everything he said. Yet, 90% of his novel was fiction. Another reason I trusted what O’Brien said was true was because I didn’t know much about what he was saying. When referring to specific war related items like, “M-16 gas-operated assault rifle...M-79 grenade... M-14s and CAR-15s” (O’Brien 5-7), I was completely ignorant to what he was referring to. All of my previous thoughts/arguments about the novel were fallacies, and were inaccurate due to misconceptions. Not knowing about the topic of war, hindered me from being able to distinguish between truth and fiction.
Although, when referring to the truth overall, I’ll leave everyone with this question, can ignorance be bliss?



Comments

  1. I feel like this is a very interesting topic to explore, and I really liked the way you did it! It was crazy to learn that O'Brien had not actually experienced the story in The Things They Carried. Upon hearing that he actually did go to Vietnam, it made the lie a little bit better because it had a fraction of the truth in it, but that mentality could be a slippery slope. Is it ok to tell a partial lie if some of it may be truth? I feel like this might also relate back to the poem we read on the first day of school. Just a little bit more to think about if you decide to go back to this topic later! I love the ideas you've come up with already!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What is the Purpose of Ingenuine Questions and Repsonses?

The purpose of polite communication is not for the purpose of desiring a genuine answer, it is used simply because the phrases are ingrained into daily communication. From a young age, we are taught polite phrases and responses that a “normal” conversation should contain. These are all classified as common, daily, or conversational phrases. When meeting someone for the first time, it is almost an innate reaction to “break the ice” with these “preloaded” phrases and questions. The purpose of learning these in the first place are for the purpose of learning basic communication skills, and just stick with us for life it seems.  Personally, when I am talking to someone, the first natural response that comes to mind is to ask them “How are you?”. The most common answers are either “I’m doing well” or “I’m fine”. There is no chance that everyone is fine or doing well! The societal purpose of asking that question isn’t to receive a genuine answer or to show concern about how the ot...

Progress Towards a Cure!

In A Measure of Restraint , Chet Raymo warns of the “dangers lurking in the human quest for scientific discovery”. While this is a valid concern in regard to his piece, with the COVID-19 virus spreading panic like wildfire across the country, some scientific discoveries couldn’t hurt, right? To ease some concerns from anyone reading this, here are some scientific discoveries and progress being made towards a vaccine and cure for the coronavirus.  One company in the process of vaccine production is I novio Pharmaceuticals. As of March 13th, their vaccine has not been tested on any humans, and isn’t approved for treatment. However, they have had preclinical testing performed between Jan. 23 and Feb. 29, and the company plans to begin clinical trials in the U.S. with 30 participants in April. Inovio stated that these trials will be conducted “only in healthy volunteers who have not been exposed to the coronavirus”. They expect to have the first results from the trials in the f...

What's the Deal With The Onion?

When going through The Onion ’s website for the first time, I became extremely intrigued. I wondered why anyone would start a fake news source and maintain it to the standards of any other prestigious online news source. So….. I did some searching!  After reading many articles, it became apparent that the most important aspect in regard to maintaining a “fake news source” is that it needs to be up to date with real news. In addition to that, it needs to parody real headlines and news, mimicking the same format. The Onion has been pumping out satirical news stories since the late ‘80s, and its odd name comes from a simple story: when the paper’s founders were reportedly so poor, they were forced to eat onion sandwiches.  I found that The Onion ’s head writer Chad Nackers had some very interesting interviews, speaking about the purpose and reason behind The Onion . Nackers stated that a large “ aspect of things that [they] satirize, [is] how the media handles things”. Wh...